A patient safety watchdog has directly linked the NHS's "advice and guidance" (A&G) referral process to patient deaths, in a finding doctors' leaders have called a "tragic vindication" of years of warnings.

The Health Services Safety Investigations Body (HSSIB) published a report in mid-August examining the scheme, under which GPs are asked to seek advice from hospital specialists before, or instead of, making a formal referral. According to the BMA, the report revealed evidence of patient harm and near misses linked to the process. Separate reporting has said the watchdog tied the process to two patient deaths and found it had "challenged and potentially removed" GPs' right to refer patients in parts of England.

Responding to the findings, BMA GP committee chair Dr Clare Bannon said GPs had voiced concern about the system since it began, arguing they know their patients and know when a referral is genuinely needed. She said the report was a "tragic vindication" of those concerns, now showing patients had been harmed by a process she described as rushed out and applied inconsistently across the country. Bannon added that a recent survey found a quarter of referrals were being diverted into advice and guidance, while genuine advice requests were sometimes taking ten days or more to get a response.

BMA consultants committee co-chairs Dr Shanu Datta and Dr Helen Neary said the harm identified should be a "wake-up call" to NHS leaders, arguing what's needed is proper resourcing for staff rather than barriers designed to keep waiting lists artificially low. They noted the scheme was introduced against the wishes of consultants, who had worked collaboratively with GPs for decades to manage referrals, and said advice and guidance work has too often gone unrecognised in consultants' job plans.

Advice and guidance has expanded rapidly since being introduced roughly a decade ago, accelerating after the pandemic as NHS England sought to cut a growing backlog of outpatient appointments. From April 2026, the scheme became a mandatory part of the GP contract in England, requiring practices to use it across ten specialties before making planned referrals — a change the RCGP and BMA had already condemned, warning it risked delaying patients' access to specialist care and piling unfunded work onto general practice. The 2026/27 contract was subsequently rejected by 99% of BMA GP members balloted, triggering ongoing collective action.

HSSIB has recommended an urgent evaluation of the scheme to address what the BMA called "clear patient safety risks." NHS England has previously defended A&G, saying it is intended to get patients the right care faster and is not a barrier to referral.

This touches on serious patient-safety concerns — if you're looking into this because of a personal case or a bereavement, organisations like INQUEST or your NHS trust's Patient Advice and Liaison Service (PALS) can help with next steps and support.

Sources: